The default license on Envato is a Split license. So only legally required parts of those themes are GPLed. It seems to me that you can’t legally resell those themes as a whole or share them with a friend. Redistributing them would require the removal of certain parts e.g. CSS, graphics, javascript etc., which are covered by a separate proprietary license. Removing those parts renders themes blank basically. Themes hosted on WordPress.org have to be 100% GPLed including assets, more than would be legally required for distributing them elsewhere.
Invention
WordPress.tv 
October 2, 2019 at 3:28 am |
What was the reference to Envato in the first question?
LikeLiked by 4 people
November 14, 2019 at 11:51 am |
The default license on Envato is a Split license. So only legally required parts of those themes are GPLed. It seems to me that you can’t legally resell those themes as a whole or share them with a friend. Redistributing them would require the removal of certain parts e.g. CSS, graphics, javascript etc., which are covered by a separate proprietary license. Removing those parts renders themes blank basically. Themes hosted on WordPress.org have to be 100% GPLed including assets, more than would be legally required for distributing them elsewhere.
Some people weren’t allowed to speak at or organise Wordcamps who sold their themes under this split-license. See also: https://designcrumbs.com/automatically-blackballed/
By now it is possible to sell 100% GPL Themes on Envato.
LikeLiked by 1 person